Pennsylvania 529 vs Maryland Save4College Analyzing Regional Options

Families across the United States face an enormous financial hurdle when preparing for the escalating costs of higher education. The landscape of college savings requires careful navigation to ensure every dollar works efficiently toward a student's academic future. Residents of the Mid-Atlantic region frequently find themselves evaluating their localized options to determine the most advantageous path for their specific household economy. A thorough examination of the Pennsylvania 529 vs Maryland Save4College programs reveals significant structural differences that can dramatically alter a family's long-term wealth accumulation. You must weigh the distinct tax incentives, investment flexibilities, and fee structures embedded within each state's offering to make an informed choice. We will dissect these two prominent regional programs meticulously to help you optimize your college savings strategy and protect your capital from unnecessary erosion.


Understanding the Core of Regional College Savings

The federal government established the 529 plan framework to encourage citizens to set aside funds for future educational requirements. These tax-advantaged accounts allow your investments to grow entirely free from federal income taxes provided you utilize the money for qualified education expenses. The individual states administer these programs independently despite their federal origin. This decentralized administration creates a highly fragmented market where the rules, benefits, and investment menus vary wildly depending on your geographic location. You are never restricted to using only your home state's plan. You can freely invest in almost any state's program across the country. Your state of residence dictates the specific tax deductions you can claim on your state income tax return. Understanding this localized dynamic is the critical first step in formulating a robust financial plan for higher education.


The Importance of State Sponsored Plans

State-sponsored plans serve as the primary vehicle for middle-class and affluent families attempting to outpace the aggressive inflation of university tuition. These programs are typically managed by massive financial institutions chosen by state treasurers to provide institutional-grade investment management at retail pricing tiers. The states themselves often heavily subsidize the administrative costs to make the plans attractive to their residents. You secure access to diversified portfolios that automatically adjust their risk profiles as your child approaches college age. The states also provide oversight and regulatory frameworks that ensure the funds are handled with fiduciary responsibility. Choosing a state-sponsored plan represents a commitment to a structured and legally protected savings environment rather than relying on standard taxable brokerage accounts.


How Geography Impacts Your Financial Benefits

Your permanent address fundamentally alters the mathematical equation of college savings. State legislatures design their tax codes to incentivize local investment and reward resident taxpayers. A family living in one state might receive a massive upfront tax deduction for contributing to their local plan while a family sitting just three miles across the border receives absolutely zero tax relief for making the exact same investment. Some states go even further by offering matching grant programs for lower-income residents or providing protection from state financial aid calculations. You must look closely at your state's specific tax code before you deposit a single dollar into any 529 plan. The geographical boundaries dictate your maximum potential return on investment before the financial markets even open for trading.



Deep Dive into the Pennsylvania 529 Program

The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania operates one of the most highly regarded and broadly flexible college savings programs in the United States. The Pennsylvania 529 College and Career Savings Program provides residents with distinct pathways tailored to entirely different financial philosophies. The state recognizes that some families prefer the potential for high market returns while other families demand absolute certainty regarding future purchasing power. This dual-structure approach makes the program incredibly attractive to a wide demographic of investors. You can choose to participate in the traditional investment plan or you can opt for a unique prepaid model that shields your capital from the volatility of the stock market. We must examine both options closely to understand how Pennsylvania caters to the diverse risk tolerances of its taxpayers.


Exploring the PA 529 Investment Plan

The PA 529 Investment Plan operates precisely like a standard 529 program found in most other states. The state partners with Vanguard to offer a robust menu of low-cost mutual funds. Your account balance will fluctuate daily based on the performance of the underlying stocks and bonds within your chosen portfolio. The plan offers excellent transparency and incredibly competitive expense ratios that prevent excessive fees from dragging down your long-term returns. You deposit cash into the account and take full responsibility for the investment outcomes. The account can grow significantly over an eighteen-year horizon if the global financial markets perform well. You also bear the entire risk of capital loss if the markets suffer a sustained downturn right before your child needs to pay for their freshman semester.


Asset Allocation and Investment Choices in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania provides investors with three primary methods for managing their asset allocation within the Investment Plan. You can select the popular target-enrollment portfolios that automatically shift your money from aggressive equities into conservative bonds as the beneficiary approaches college age. This hands-off approach is mathematically ideal for parents who lack the time or desire to monitor market conditions actively. You can also choose from various static portfolios that maintain a constant target allocation if you prefer to retain manual control over your risk exposure. The plan even offers individual core fund options for highly sophisticated investors who wish to build their own customized allocation models from scratch. The partnership with Vanguard ensures that every portfolio utilizes broad market index funds to minimize active management risks.


Unpacking the PA 529 Guaranteed Savings Plan

The PA 529 Guaranteed Savings Plan represents a completely different philosophy regarding educational finance. This plan is not based on stock market returns at all. It is based entirely on the actual cost of college tuition. You contribute money to the plan today to purchase specific college credits at today's prices. When your child enrolls in college years later, the plan pays out enough money to cover those exact credits regardless of how much the tuition has increased in the interim. This mechanism completely transfers the risk of tuition inflation from your family directly to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. You sleep soundly knowing that a semester paid for today will be fully covered a decade from now even if the university doubles its pricing structure.


Locking in Tomorrow's Tuition at Today's Prices

The mechanics of the Guaranteed Savings Plan require you to select a specific tuition level when you open the account. You can peg your savings to the average cost of a community college, a state-owned university, or even an Ivy League institution. The value of your account grows at the exact rate of tuition inflation for the tier you selected. If the tuition at your selected tier increases by six percent in a given year, the value of your accumulated credits increases by exactly six percent. This plan is phenomenally powerful for risk-averse families who cannot tolerate the thought of a stock market crash wiping out their college savings. The primary drawback is that your returns will never outpace tuition inflation. You sacrifice the potential for massive stock market gains in exchange for an absolute guarantee against the soaring costs of academia.


Tax Advantages for Pennsylvania Residents

Pennsylvania offers one of the most incredibly generous and taxpayer-friendly environments for college savings in the entire country. The state recognizes the crushing burden of student debt and actively uses its tax code to encourage early preparation. A married couple filing jointly can deduct a massive amount of their 529 contributions from their taxable income each year. The state taxes these investments highly favorably upon withdrawal as long as the funds are directed toward appropriate educational expenses. The state also completely exempts the assets held within a PA 529 plan from the calculation of state financial aid eligibility. This specific exemption ensures that families are never punished for saving money when their children apply for state-level educational grants.


The Parity Rule and State Income Tax Deductions

The absolute most unique feature of Pennsylvania's tax code regarding college savings is its implementation of the tax parity rule. The vast majority of states require you to use their specific state-sponsored plan to claim a state income tax deduction. Pennsylvania does not enforce this restriction. A Pennsylvania resident can invest their money in literally any 529 plan in the entire United States and still claim the full Pennsylvania state income tax deduction. You can live in Philadelphia and invest your money in the Utah 529 plan, the New York 529 plan, or the Maryland Save4College plan, and Pennsylvania will gladly process your tax deduction exactly as if you had used their proprietary system. This incredible flexibility allows Pennsylvania residents to shop the entire national market for the absolute lowest fees without ever sacrificing their local tax benefits.


Feature Comparison PA 529 Investment Plan PA 529 Guaranteed Savings Plan
Growth Mechanism Stock and bond market performance. Tuition inflation rates.
Primary Investment Risk Market volatility and capital loss. Tuition rising slower than general market returns.
Investment Manager Vanguard Group. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
Tax Deduction Up to $18,000 per individual contributor. Up to $18,000 per individual contributor.
Best Suited For Families comfortable with market fluctuations. Highly conservative families seeking price certainty.

Comprehensive Review of Maryland Save4College

The state of Maryland offers its own highly competitive college savings infrastructure designed to rival the programs of its immediate neighbors. The Maryland Save4College system provides residents with multiple avenues for wealth accumulation and tax optimization. The state has historically focused on providing high-quality investment management while actively trying to incentivize lower-income and middle-income families to participate in the savings culture. Maryland also operates a dual-structure system that includes both a standard investment plan and a prepaid trust option. We must scrutinize the Maryland system to understand how it leverages local tax codes and unique state matching programs to build loyalty among its resident taxpayers.


The Maryland Senator Edward J Kasemeyer College Investment Plan

The primary vehicle for most Maryland residents is the Maryland Senator Edward J. Kasemeyer College Investment Plan. This program operates as a traditional market-based 529 account. You select your portfolios and the underlying mutual funds dictate your long-term success or failure. Maryland partners with T. Rowe Price, a highly respected financial institution headquartered in Baltimore, to manage the assets within this plan. This localized partnership provides investors with access to actively managed mutual funds rather than relying strictly on passive index funds. Actively managed funds attempt to outperform the broader market through strategic stock picking. This approach occasionally results in higher gross returns but typically carries slightly higher internal expense ratios compared to purely passive strategies.


Portfolio Options and Risk Tolerance for Marylanders

The Maryland College Investment Plan offers a comprehensive suite of enrollment-based portfolios that automatically become more conservative over time. These portfolios are heavily populated with T. Rowe Price equity and fixed-income mutual funds. You can also build your own strategy using static portfolios if you prefer to maintain a specific ratio of stocks to bonds regardless of the beneficiary's current age. The plan caters effectively to all levels of risk tolerance. A young family with a newborn can select a portfolio that is invested almost entirely in aggressive global equities to maximize long-term growth potential. A family with a high school junior can select a highly conservative portfolio consisting entirely of short-term bond funds and cash equivalents to protect their accumulated wealth from a sudden market crash.


Examining the Maryland Prepaid College Trust

Maryland also offers the Maryland Prepaid College Trust which allows families to lock in future tuition at today's rates. You purchase semesters or years of tuition based on current pricing structures. The trust guarantees that it will cover the cost of tuition and mandatory fees at Maryland public colleges when your child eventually enrolls. You can also use the value of the trust at out-of-state or private institutions, though the payout is typically capped at the weighted average tuition of Maryland's public universities. This trust provides massive peace of mind for families absolutely certain that their child will attend a state school within Maryland. It shields your capital entirely from the unpredictable swings of the Wall Street indices.


Managing the State Contribution Match Incentive

One of the most compelling reasons to choose the Maryland Save4College system is the state's unique matching grant program. The Maryland State Contribution Program offers an incredibly powerful incentive for lower-income and middle-income families to begin saving. Eligible families who open a new account and make a minimum required contribution can receive a matching grant directly from the state government. The state will deposit up to five hundred dollars directly into the child's 529 account. This matching program provides an instant and guaranteed return on your initial investment that is mathematically impossible to achieve in any standard financial market. Families must meet specific income thresholds and apply before annual legislative deadlines to secure these funds. This program actively democratizes college savings across the state.


Tax Benefits Specific to Maryland Residents

Maryland rewards its residents with a specific and highly localized tax benefit structure. An individual taxpayer can deduct up to two thousand five hundred dollars per beneficiary per year from their Maryland adjusted gross income for contributions made to the Maryland College Investment Plan. A married couple filing jointly can deduct up to five thousand dollars per beneficiary per year. This deduction directly lowers your state tax liability and provides excellent annual cash flow relief for families actively funding multiple accounts. The tax benefits compound significantly when you have two or three children and fund each of their accounts simultaneously. The state also allows these investments to grow entirely tax-free at the state level just as they do at the federal level.


Income Deductions and Recapture Rules Explained

Maryland implements a strict set of rules regarding its state income tax deductions. You must invest your money specifically in the Maryland Save4College plans to claim the Maryland state tax deduction. Maryland does not offer tax parity like Pennsylvania. If a Maryland resident invests in the Pennsylvania 529 plan, they forfeit their Maryland state tax deduction entirely. The state also allows a remarkable ten-year carryforward for contributions that exceed the annual deduction limit. If you deposit ten thousand dollars in a single year, you can deduct two thousand five hundred dollars this year and carry the remaining balance forward to deduct over the next three consecutive tax years. You must also be fiercely aware of the state's recapture rules. If you execute a non-qualified withdrawal or roll the funds to an out-of-state plan, Maryland requires you to add those previously deducted amounts back into your taxable income immediately.



Direct Comparison Between the Neighboring Programs

You must place the Pennsylvania 529 and the Maryland Save4College plans side by side to evaluate their true mathematical efficiency. We have established the core mechanics and the specific tax environments of each program. The final decision often rests on comparing the underlying costs and the operational flexibility that each state provides. A small difference in annual administrative fees can quietly destroy thousands of dollars of compound growth over an eighteen-year horizon. We must analyze how these programs treat your capital and how easily you can adapt your strategy if your family's educational plans shift unexpectedly during the high school years.


Fee Structures and Administrative Costs

The long-term performance of your college savings is heavily dependent on the fees you pay to the fund managers. The Pennsylvania 529 Investment Plan utilizes Vanguard index funds which are renowned globally for their rock-bottom expense ratios. The total annual asset-based fees in the Pennsylvania plan are exceptionally low, frequently hovering around a small fraction of one percent. This ultra-low fee structure allows the vast majority of your investment returns to remain inside your account compounding for your child's benefit. The Maryland College Investment Plan utilizes T. Rowe Price actively managed funds. Actively managed funds inherently cost more to operate because they employ teams of analysts attempting to beat the market averages. The Maryland plan's overall expense ratios are generally higher than the Pennsylvania plan's expense ratios. You must decide whether you believe T. Rowe Price's active management can generate enough excess return to justify the higher annual costs.


Which Plan Offers Better Long Term Value

Determining the better long-term value requires a strict mathematical assessment of your residency and your investment philosophy. A Pennsylvania resident receives the absolute best value by utilizing the PA 529 Investment Plan because they capture the massive state tax deduction while enjoying Vanguard's incredibly low fees. A Maryland resident faces a much more difficult calculation. The Maryland resident must use the slightly more expensive Maryland plan to capture the Maryland state tax deduction. If the Maryland resident uses the cheaper Pennsylvania plan, they lose their state tax benefit. The math typically suggests that the value of the state tax deduction far outweighs the slightly higher fees over an eighteen-year period. The Maryland plan is usually the optimal choice for a Maryland resident specifically because the tax code forces their hand.



Flexibility and Qualified Education Expenses

Both the Pennsylvania and Maryland programs adhere strictly to federal guidelines regarding what constitutes a qualified higher education expense. You can use the funds from either plan to pay for university tuition, mandatory institutional fees, required textbooks, computer equipment, and room and board for students enrolled at least half-time. The funds are never restricted to colleges within the sponsoring state. You can use money from a Pennsylvania 529 plan to pay for a student attending the University of Maryland, and you can use money from a Maryland Save4College plan to pay for a student attending Penn State University. Both programs provide excellent geographic flexibility for the student.


Using Funds Across State Lines and for K through 12

Recent federal legislation expanded the definition of qualified expenses to include up to ten thousand dollars per year for K through 12 private school tuition. Both Pennsylvania and Maryland allow residents to utilize their 529 funds for these primary and secondary educational costs without triggering state-level penalties. This expansion fundamentally altered how families utilize these accounts. You can now use a 529 plan to fund a private elementary school education before the child ever reaches a university campus. You must exercise extreme caution with this strategy because draining the account during the elementary years destroys the massive mathematical power of long-term tax-free compound interest that was originally intended to cover the vastly more expensive university tuition bills.


Attribute Pennsylvania 529 Maryland Save4College
State Tax Deduction Rule Tax Parity. Residents can deduct contributions to ANY state's plan. Restrictive. Residents must use the MD plan to claim the MD deduction.
State Matching Grant None currently offered at the state level. Yes. Up to $500 for eligible lower/middle-income families.
Investment Strategy Primarily passive index funds (Vanguard). Primarily actively managed funds (T. Rowe Price).
Carryforward Provision No specific carryforward needed due to high annual limits. Excellent 10-year carryforward for excess contributions.

Real World Financial Trade Offs and Scenarios

Abstract tax laws and fee structures are difficult to grasp without placing them into the context of actual human decision making. Every family faces a highly specific set of financial constraints and long-term goals. We must examine concrete scenarios to understand the brutal trade-offs parents navigate when balancing multiple competing financial priorities. These examples illustrate exactly how the specific rules of Pennsylvania and Maryland dictate entirely different strategic approaches for families living just a few dozen miles apart. Analyzing these real-world dilemmas provides actionable clarity for your own planning process.


Scenario One A Middle Income Family in Philadelphia

Consider a middle-income family residing in Philadelphia trying to save for their newborn daughter's future education. They have a limited monthly budget and want to ensure every dollar is maximized. Because they live in Pennsylvania, they benefit from the state's tax parity rule. They are not forced to use the Pennsylvania plan to get their state tax deduction. They decide to extensively research the national market. They ultimately choose to invest their money directly into the PA 529 Investment Plan anyway. They make this decision because the Vanguard index funds offer the lowest possible fees and they appreciate the convenience of dealing with their home state's administrative portal. They happily deduct their monthly contributions on their Pennsylvania state income tax return. They face a critical trade-off when their daughter reaches her junior year of high school. They have accumulated forty thousand dollars but project a tuition shortfall. They must decide whether to stop their own retirement contributions to pump more cash into the 529 plan or accept the reality that their daughter will need to take out federal student loans.


Balancing State Benefits with Investment Control

This Philadelphia family prioritizes total investment control and absolute lowest costs. They intentionally sacrifice the price certainty of the PA Guaranteed Savings Plan because they firmly believe the stock market will drastically outpace tuition inflation over an eighteen-year timeline. They understand the risk of market volatility and accept it willingly. When faced with the tuition shortfall during the high school years, they make the difficult but correct decision to maintain their retirement contributions and utilize small federal student loans to bridge the gap. They understand that destroying their own long-term financial security to avoid student loans is a catastrophic mistake. The Pennsylvania tax parity rule gave them the freedom to shop around, but the fundamental quality of the PA 529 Investment Plan ultimately won their business organically.


Scenario Two A Grandparent Residing in Baltimore

Imagine a wealthy grandparent living in Baltimore who wants to reduce the size of their taxable estate while securing their newly born grandson's future. The grandparent has fifty thousand dollars in liquid cash available to deploy immediately. They are a Maryland resident and are therefore bound by Maryland's restrictive tax rules. If they deposit the money into a Vanguard 529 plan in Nevada or Pennsylvania, they lose all state tax benefits. They decide to utilize the Maryland Senator Edward J. Kasemeyer College Investment Plan to execute a superfunding strategy. They deposit the entire fifty thousand dollars into the Maryland plan in a single day. This maneuver legally accelerates five years of federal gift tax exemptions into a single lump sum deposit without triggering federal gift taxes.


Maximizing Legacy Wealth Transfer and State Matches

The Baltimore grandparent leverages the Maryland tax code brilliantly. They claim the maximum two thousand five hundred dollar state income tax deduction in the current year. Because Maryland offers a highly generous ten-year carryforward provision, the grandparent will continue to claim a two thousand five hundred dollar deduction every single year for the next nineteen years until the entire fifty thousand dollar initial deposit has been fully deducted from their state taxes. The grandparent accepted the slightly higher fees of the T. Rowe Price active management specifically to capture this massive, multi-decade state tax benefit. This scenario perfectly demonstrates how a wealthy family uses the specific mechanics of the Maryland tax code to execute a flawless generational wealth transfer while simultaneously reducing their own annual tax liability.



Strategic Considerations for Out of State Investors

You might wonder why anyone would bother researching the Pennsylvania or Maryland plans if they live in Texas or California. The 529 marketplace is entirely national. State borders do not restrict your ability to invest. Many families live in states that offer absolutely zero state income tax deductions for college savings. Residents of Florida, Texas, and Washington have no local tax incentives to keep their money at home. These families are free agents who roam the national market searching for the absolute best combination of low fees and high-quality investment options. The Pennsylvania and Maryland plans both actively compete for these out-of-state investment dollars.


Why Residents Might Look Beyond Their Borders

An out-of-state investor evaluating these two programs will focus almost entirely on the investment lineup and the administrative expense ratios. They do not care about the Maryland state tax deduction or the Pennsylvania tax parity rule because those localized benefits do not apply to their out-of-state tax returns. An investor living in Texas might look closely at the Pennsylvania 529 Investment Plan because the Vanguard index fund lineup is universally respected and incredibly cheap to maintain. The out-of-state investor simply wants a reliable vault to hold their money while it compounds tax-free at the federal level. They prioritize simplicity and historical performance over regional loyalty.


Evaluating National Options Against State Loyalty

The Maryland plan frequently struggles to attract out-of-state investors specifically because its primary competitive advantage is its localized state tax deduction. When you remove the tax deduction from the mathematical equation, the actively managed T. Rowe Price funds within the Maryland plan often look expensive compared to the passive Vanguard funds within the Pennsylvania plan or the Fidelity funds offered by other states. Out-of-state investors generally gravitate toward programs that prioritize absolute minimal costs. The Pennsylvania 529 Investment Plan frequently ranks highly on national lists specifically for this reason. You must strip away your local biases and evaluate these programs strictly on their mathematical merits if your home state does not bribe you with tax deductions to stay local.



Final Personal Thoughts on Choosing a College Savings Path

I find the process of dissecting these complex financial vehicles endlessly fascinating because the rules shift completely depending on your geographic coordinates. I look at the Pennsylvania tax parity rule and view it as a magnificent piece of legislation that genuinely respects the taxpayer's right to seek the best product on the open market. I look at the Maryland state matching program and see an incredibly honorable attempt to pull lower-income families into the wealth-building ecosystem. The stark reality is that there is no absolute right or wrong answer when choosing between these plans. The math dictates the optimal path based entirely on where you sleep at night and how much risk you can tolerate in your portfolio.

I continually observe families agonizing over which specific fund to choose while completely missing the larger picture. The most important action you can ever take regarding college savings is simply starting the process. The raw power of compound interest heavily favors the family who opens a mediocre plan when a child is one year old over the family who opens the perfect plan when the child is fifteen years old. You should leverage your localized tax benefits to the absolute maximum extent possible, automate your monthly contributions, and then refuse to panic when the financial markets inevitably fluctuate. Building a durable financial safety net for the next generation requires immense patience and a steadfast refusal to let the perfect become the enemy of the good.



Frequently Asked Questions

Essential Queries Regarding Pennsylvania and Maryland 529 Plans

Can a Maryland resident use the Pennsylvania 529 plan for their child's education?
Yes, a Maryland resident can freely open and fund a Pennsylvania 529 plan. The funds can be used at any eligible university in the country. The Maryland resident will simply forfeit their right to claim the Maryland state income tax deduction because Maryland law requires residents to use the Maryland Save4College plan to secure that specific tax benefit.

Will I lose my Pennsylvania state tax deduction if I choose to invest in the Maryland plan?
No, you will not lose your deduction. Pennsylvania operates under a tax parity rule. A Pennsylvania resident can invest their money in the Maryland Save4College plan, or any other state's 529 plan, and still claim the full Pennsylvania state income tax deduction on their annual return.

Does the PA Guaranteed Savings Plan guarantee admission to a Pennsylvania university?
No, the PA 529 Guaranteed Savings Plan only guarantees the future financial cost of the college credits based on the tier you selected. It provides absolutely no preference or guarantee regarding the student's actual academic admission into any specific university or college system.

Can I rollover funds from a Maryland 529 plan into a Pennsylvania 529 plan?
You can execute a tax-free rollover from one state's 529 plan to another state's plan once per twelve-month period. You must be extremely careful if you are a Maryland resident attempting this maneuver. Rolling funds out of the Maryland plan to an out-of-state plan will trigger a strict recapture rule requiring you to pay back the state tax deductions you previously claimed.

What happens if my child receives a full scholarship and does not need the 529 funds?
You will never lose the money. Both the Pennsylvania and Maryland plans allow you to change the designated beneficiary to another qualifying family member seamlessly. You can also withdraw funds up to the exact dollar amount of the tax-free scholarship without facing the standard ten percent IRS penalty on the earnings portion.

Are the investment options in these plans FDIC insured against market losses?
The standard investment portfolios in both the PA 529 Investment Plan and the Maryland College Investment Plan are tied to the stock and bond markets and are absolutely not FDIC insured. They can lose value. Only specific, highly conservative cash preservation options within these plans might carry FDIC protection for the principal amount.

Can I use these funds to pay off my own existing student loans?
Yes, recent federal legislation allows you to withdraw a lifetime maximum of ten thousand dollars from a 529 plan to pay down qualified student loans for the designated beneficiary or their siblings without incurring federal tax penalties. Both Pennsylvania and Maryland conform to this federal rule.


Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or tax advice. The rules governing 529 plans, state tax deductions, and IRS tax codes change frequently and vary drastically by state. Always consult with a qualified financial advisor, tax professional, or certified accountant before making any significant financial decisions, executing major account rollovers, or filing your annual tax returns to ensure compliance with current laws and to address your specific personal circumstances.